Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

The Only Thing You Have To Do Is Be II

Cowboy Cottage Cattle Pasture, East Napa, California, USA

August 23, 2022

"The way it is, is enough. Who you are is enough. The only thing you have to do is be." ... 
"Trying to be happy by accumulating possessions is like trying to satisfy hunger by taping sandwiches all over your body." ... George Carlin
"Too much is never enough." ... David Bowie
"Oh, Life is bigger, it's bigger than you, and you are not me." ... R.E.M., Losing My Religion
This essay, The Only Thing You Have To Do Is Be II, is the companion piece to The Only Game In Town.

It is also the sequel to The Only Thing You Have To Do Is Be.




This all started with being. All of it. Just being. Way back when. "In the beginning was being ..." (as one of those bibles may have said) and the genesis of this. Back then, all there was was being. The only thing you had to do was be. Being was enough then. It's still enough now. But you forget that from time to time, don't you?

Why? We human  beings are thrown  that something more's needed. Maybe we're this way because of a cosmic joke  the creator plays on us (like the whack  of the Zen master's wooden broadsword) to ensure we're paying attention. Who knows  why? For whatever the reason, we're thrown to buy into that being is not enough.

So to get enough, we add things, we change things, we take things away. No, it's worse than that actually. It's that we're convinced that if we're going to bang life into a shape that'll be enough, we must  add things, we must change things, we must take things away - all of which only adds more concerns. Then we have to solve those concerns because concerns get in the way of just being ie they get in the way of being enough. But that doesn't work either. It's never enough. So we add a few more things and we change a few more things and we take a few more things away - all of which only ensures more concerns are added which we then also try to solve. Why do we? Because we're thrown to. And because we're thrown that when we do, it'll be enough. Look around you. Tell the truth: how's that going for you?

So: first there was being - just being. And it was enough. Then came things and solving concerns, all of which just added shrapnel to the hand-grenade. Soon all our concerns obscured just being, and being enough. With being obscured, it's never enough. In our thrown attempts to make it enough, we circuitously add more things and try solving more concerns, truly none of which is ever enough. We ascribe that to "the way it is". That's not it. It's not that at all. It's that without being, "the way it is" is never  enough ... and with  being, "the way it is" is enough (paradoxically our certainty that it's never enough, undermines experiencing that being is enough).

For sure, that's not an easy get - not because we can't  get it, but because we're thrown not to. It's why bringing back being calls for confronting our thrown-ness.

We're thrown that it's not enough, that something more's needed. We infer (albeit erroneously) from the seeming not-enough-ness  of our own lives, that it's smart (very  smart) to add things, to change things, and to take things away. We're adaptable organisms. We're thrown to adapt. So we adapt. We add. We change. We take away - because that's what adaptable organisms do. And then as a by-product of being adaptable, we must deal with all the new concerns that arise when we adapt.

Dealing with all the new concerns that arise when we adapt, is also what adaptable organisms are thrown to do. But that's not the highest expression of our humanity (it can't be: remember, we're thrown that whatever we do, is never enough). The highest expression of our humanity is being. When we're being adaptable, that's our thrown-ness. But when we're being being (not a typo) we're being uniquely human. You will adapt. It's required to make your life work. But you don't have to. The only thing you have to do is be. And beyond merely being being (because the only thing you have  to do is be), mastering  being is what it is to master being human.

Being is enough. Who you are is enough. It's enough to just be. And if it's not enough to just be, that's your thrown-ness having gotten the better of you. Be in life. "In the beginning was being ..." (as one of those bibles may have said). Look: you can't spell "beginning" without "being", and you can't spell "being" without "be in".



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2022 Permission