Conversations For Transformation: Essays Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

Conversations For Transformation

Essays By Laurence Platt

Inspired By The Ideas Of Werner Erhard

And More


GoFundMe

Roses Through Barbed Wire:

A New Treatise On Being Happy

Canard Vineyard, Calistoga Appellation, Napa Valley, California, USA

September 1, 2023



"Happiness is almost not worth talking about because the instant you turn happiness into a goal, it isn't attainable any more. In other words happiness isn't something you can work toward. It isn't something you can put someplace and overcome barriers to get to. It is something that happens in an instant. And the truth of the matter is that you can alter your state of happiness by simply choosing to be willing to have it be the way it is."
... 
This essay, Roses Through Barbed Wire: A New Treatise On Being Happy, is the companion piece to It is also the fifth in a septology on Happiness:
  1. Contribution II: Happiness
  2. On Being Happy
  3. "I Want Her To Be Happy"
  4. Bring Happiness To Life
  5. Roses Through Barbed Wire: A New Treatise On Being Happy
  6. Do Nothing, Be Happy
  7. Being Happy Like A Possibility
in that order.

I am indebted to Sydney Rittenberg who inspired this conversation, and to Paige Rose PhD who contributed material.




After a prolonged period of scrutiny and discovery, I realized that part of the issue I've had with being happy (or not) was not knowing exactly what being happy is. Look: not being able to articulate clearly  what being happy is, is to not know what being happy is. Mostly we conceptualize  what being happy is, and yet whatever that is, is really just a pointer  to a state of mind (albeit a nebulous experience). But that state of mind ie that experience may be better articulated more powerfully in some way other than "happy". "Content" may work better: "I am content.". "Fulfilled" may work even better: "I am fulfilled.". "Complete"  may work best: "I am complete.". Whatever it is that we cast as being "happy" may be better articulated as being "content", "fulfilled", or "complete", or even "alright" or "whole". Still, with all of that distinguished, saying being "happy" is good enough for jazz  (at least it is for the time being).

One of the themes that's always been meandering throughout my life, is that talking with people ie including them, is so much smarter than trying to figure it all out or even trying to handle (most of) it by myself. I notice all I have in here  (ie in my own head) are the same old same old thoughts, the same old same old usual gang of suspects that have rattled around in there forever. Allowing other people in, talking openly, freely, unflinchingly honestly  with them (my friends, my coaches, my loved-ones) inspires new useful, valuable, worthwhile ideas on which I may have taken too long to alight, if at all (ie if ever).

And so it was recently in a conversation with one of my coaches, that something dawned on me, and I'd had a breakthrough in the way I held being happy. One of the ways I'd idealized being happy is that when I'm happy, it's as if I've filled a bucket with water, expecting it to stay full - in other words when I'm happy, there's an expectation I'll be that way from then on (ie that the filled bucket will stay full like an attainment). But that's not the true nature of being happy, and holding it as true invariably leads to disappointment. What's true is I'm happy ... and then I'm not ... and then I'm happy ... and then I'm not ... and then I'm happy ... you know, it's transient, impermanent. I realized my old ideas about being happy had to grow up. I had to take a maturer approach.

To have being happy be like a bucket filled with water such that once it's filled, it stays full ... is naïve in retrospect. That's being happy like a goal  or like a place to get to  or to attain. But if I can choose to be "content", "fulfilled', or "complete" with whatever's  going on in my relationship with the conditions and circumstances of my life ie if I choose to be willing to be that way rather than go for the somewhat nebulous / vague "happy", then I have something I can articulate clearly (which makes it powerful) and I also have something that doesn't go away when my life's conditions and circumstances change, in the way being happy changes (starts and stops, comes again then goes away, full bucket / empty bucket) dependent on my life's conditions and circumstances.

Try it on for size. It's a way of having the possibility of being happy always be available, even on occasions when that once-full bucket is no longer full (for whatever the reason). Even when outside my window I may see barbed wire fencing me in, crimping my being happy and my being free to be and free to act, it's still possible to appreciate roses through barbed wire - that is, should I choose to be willing to do so. If I don't choose to do so (as per Werner's coaching) ie if I'm unwilling to have it be the way it is, it's on me. I already know how it turns out. I bin  there before (as Huckleberry Finn may have said).



Communication Promise E-Mail | Home

© Laurence Platt - 2023, 2024 Permission